| Author | Comment | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
bswild |
A fly that OUGHT to be a classic. |
Lead | ||
|
I fished the upper Kinnickinnic River last night. The temps were in the low 70s. The only hatch was a spinner fall of tiny blue winged olives, which were size
#26, and not enough of them falling to raise many fish. So, I put on my "adams," my prospecting fly, which is Chuck Stranahan's Caddis Variant. I
fished for only a half hour and caught eight browns. Not surprising, considering the attraction this fly has for trout. The Caddis Variant is tied on a Tiemco
921, a short-shanked dry fly hook. Dai-Riki and Targus makes versions of it, too. The hackle--grizzly died a ginger color--is one size larger than the hook
size and wound at the front of the fly, catskill style. The wing is splayed deer hair; the body is a strand of wound and twisted antron yarn, made to look like
a fat quill body. I tie a dark and light version of the fly, using a yellow or brown body. One could tie it in tan and olive, of course. But the colors I use
work so well that I don't need any other variations. I discovered the Caddis Variant from Jack Dennis's book, "Tying Flies With Jack Dennis and
Friends." I learned to tie the fat antron body from the website, "Charlie's Fly Box," which has a great tutorial on tying the fly (But in
the sizes I tie, I use just one hackle). I love this fly. It floats high. It's easy to see. And it raises far more fish for me than the elk hair caddis
ever did. It mimics the real proportions of a caddis fly, which has a body half the length of it's wing. The grizzly hackle gives it the look of a
fluttering caddis; and the fat body looks like that of the real bug. Check out the caddis variant by clicking onto Charlie's Fly Box at:
www.charliesflyboxinc.com/flybox/details.cfm?parentID=8 I've seen some Caddis Variants that were commercially available. But they were tied with the wrong
proportions. Chuck Stranahan, the fly's originator has a fly shop that sells the originals. I believe it's called "Chuck Stranahan's Flies and
Guides." Check it out.
|
||||
|
|
||||
lstshkr |
#1 | |||
|
So, do you think the same fly would have that effect on the Rush? A buddy and I were fishing north of Stonehammer Bridge and got into a spot where the fish
were rising all around us - I mean there were 4-5 fish on the surface at one time - all within a short cast from us. They stayed about six inches under the
surface and hovered until they saw what they wanted - it was very interesting watching them hover and strike. We tried everything we could think of (although
we didn't try a beetle fly), but even dropping our flies on top of them, we couldn't get any interest. Actually, one brownie actually struck my leader
knot while ignoring the fly! This has happened a couple times now, and I'd like to get a few of these on the line! Now, I admit my learning curve is still
pretty steep - fly identification is still a real weak spot in my knowledge of fishing - but I think I have the basic skill to catch some of these critters if
I have the right fly.
I checked the website you provided, and I think I'll try to tie up a few of the Variants before I go out again next week (probably Monday). I was wondering what size you would recommend for the Kinni and the Rush? Any other tips? Thanks, Dean
"I used to be clueless, but I've turned that situation around 360 degrees."
|
||||
|
|
||||
CreationBear |
#2 | |||
|
I've been thinking of tying some of those up ever since reading Charlie's great tutorial, but worried that the oversized hackle would lead to it being
"tippy" (at least when constructed with my rudimentary skills.) The 921 keeps it riding on an even keel?
|
||||
|
|
||||
bswild |
A fly that OUGHT to be a classic. | #3 | ||
|
The wing rides up over the body of the fly. The oversized hackle acts almost like the hackle of a parachute fly. The fat, segmented body rides in the water,
with the wing and hackle overhead. Stranahan's favorite variation of the fly is the Light Caddis Variant, with a yellow body and ginger/grizzly hackle. The
#921 hook is a must.
|
||||
|
|
||||
CreationBear |
#4 | |||
|
Thanks for the info...and that light variant ought to work in my neck of the woods.
|
||||
|
|
||||
thegubster |
Thanks Bill! | #5 | ||
|
Sounds like just the searching fly I've been looking for up there!
Carry on.... |
||||
|
|
||||
johnr |
classic fly picture? | #6 | ||
|
any substitution for a thousand words???
I just do better with visuals thanks |
||||
|
|
||||
thegubster |
#7 | |||
johnr wrote: Scroll down..... http://www.charliesflyboxinc.com/flybox/details.cfm?parentID=8 |
||||
|
|
||||
johnr |
the perfect tie | #8 | ||
|
thanks JG
|
||||
|
|
||||
oldtrout |
#9 | |||
|
Not unlike a drug pusher, that very same Chuck Stranahan fellow got me started on bamboo.
In spite of this, I still think he's a nice guy. And I can vouch for his flies. |
||||
|
|
||||
riverfloggin |
#10 | |||
|
Is there any reason a short-shanked (and not too stout) nymph hook wouldn't work as a substitute for the 921?
|
||||
|
|
||||
bswild |
a fly that OUGHT to be a classic. | #11 | ||
|
It may be harder to keep afloat.
|
||||
|
|
||||
CreationBear |
#12 | |||
|
Since we seem to be "feeling" Chuck Stranahan lately, I was wondering if any of you gentlemen might have the recipe for his "Brindle
'chute" and Amber Trude patterns--I really like his fly design philosophy.
Recipes for his Caddis Variant as well as his other Trudes are easy to find on the Web, but I haven't been able to track these two down...
|
||||
|
|
||||