I agree that a lot of times the question comes as confrontational (although not yesterday). Most fisherman that ask, don't want a real answer, they're looking to verify their preconceived notion that I'm trying to be trendy.
| Author | Comment | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
Armchair Angler |
why the cane rod? | #61 | ||
|
I was asked this yesterday while walking off the stream. I told him "its just a little something special for my fishing - I like they way they're
made".
I agree that a lot of times the question comes as confrontational (although not yesterday). Most fisherman that ask, don't want a real answer, they're looking to verify their preconceived notion that I'm trying to be trendy. |
||||
|
|
||||
Boonut |
#62 | |||
|
There's an advantage to being an old guy. I think most think it's all i've ever used.
|
||||
|
|
||||
Armchair Angler |
#63 | |||
|
I agree that my age (40) and lack of
gray invites the indignant attitude. (It was worse when I was 30.) Regardless,
I fish cane in spite of how I'm judged on the stream, although I will swing the rod behind me if I see a fisherman on a trail. I'd rather just avoid the inquiries - not so much to avoid an insult, but because anymore I'm liable to smack an arrogant
smirk. |
||||
|
|
||||
fyshstix |
?Why | #64 | ||
|
It is one of my true pleasures. Best when shared.
|
||||
|
|
||||
OnlyTrout |
#65 | |||
|
Even though I already responded to this question, after reading all the responses and thinking about it I felt compelled to reply again. It seems some of the
responses are defensive: I like the feel (opps - I said that too), I like the looks and craftmanship, I like the history, I like the attachment to the natural
world, etc. While I do agree with all that, it seems like many of us give pat answers to those graphite guys who challenge us on the stream to avoid a
confrontation. I understand - who wants their beautiful "trout"day ruined by these jerks? But I don't really believe that we spend the extra
money just because we like the way cane looks, or the history, etc. When it comes down to it - it's about catching fish. I will say to anyone without
hesitation that cane makes me a better fisherman. This revelation came to me last fall when I was fishing out west for 2 weeks. My two friends I fished with
always use graphite and I outfished them - really bad. It was technical, stalking type fishing. Both of them complimented my casting stroke, the accuracy and
the softness of the fly landing on the water. I have had compliments before but this time it hit me that cane does make me a better fisherman. Usually I go
out fishing to fish a minumum of 5 hours and quike frankly I don't use graphite because I don't want to work that hard - it gets me tired. Cane does
the work for me. AND because cane slows the cast down I get immense eye pleasure in watching my "slow" cast unfold to the exact spot I was aiming
for. In addition, slow casts can be corrected easier that those speedy tight looped casts. I will not back away from any challange to my usage of cane versus
graphite but will simple tell them it's because it makes me cast better - resulting in more fish caught - and released.
|
||||
|
|
||||
Canewrap |
Re: Why do you fish a bamboo rod? | #66 | ||
|
I think OnlyTrout has the best answer to this question I've seen. If graphite cast and "felt" the way bamboo does I would still be fishing it. I
don't fish to look good, or trendy. I fish because I like to do it.
|
||||
|
|
||||
canenut |
Still Beating that dead horse | #67 | ||
|
(no offense meant Marty
)
It's an easy answer: Because it makes me happy!
I can feel them load and I like the way they cast. Their slower stroke fits my casting style. I feel that they are a better material than graphite, but I don't say that they are more superior to graphite to avoid the argument with the yuppies. I like the history and romance of bamboo rods for the same reason I like Colt Single Action Armies and Winchester Rifles and SXS shotguns.
Besides, I'm an Old Fart and proud of it!
The trout takes the fly, the line tightens and it's like I was blind, but now I
see.
|
||||
|
|
||||
57Clemson |
#68 | |||
|
I couldn't aford to buy one so I made a cane and started fishing it---never looked back.
|
||||
|
|
||||
teter |
#69 | |||
|
I can't remember the last time someone asked me WHY I was fishing bamboo, but a lot of guys have commented on it - and almost every comment was along
the lines of "I've been thinking about getting into bamboo, but..." which is usually followed by a phrase like "they cost too much" or
"I'm afraid I would break it"or "it's too slow" or "too heavy." There isn't much of an argument to be made about
cost; yes, bamboo is more likely to increase in value or at least not decrease much, but clearly, a high-level bamboo rod is almost always going to cost a lot
more than a high-level graphite rod. As for the other concerns, I point out that bamboo is tougher than graphite and that a hollowbuilt bamboo rod can compare
favorably to graphite in both weight and speed. After casting one of my rods, these guys nearly always profess admiration for its qualities. How many of them
actually go on to buy or build a bamboo rod, I have no idea.
As for my own reasons, there are many -- I like the way bamboo looks, as opposed to a piece of colored plastic; I love the way it flexes, smells, even sounds, and above all, the way it feels when I hook and play a fish. I like that it is a natural material; just as I prefer cotton and wool clothes to polyester, like real leather uppers and soles on my shoes, prefer wood gun stocks to plastic, and prefer leather or cloth car seats to vinyl. Plastics have been of great benefit to the world, but there is something solid and substantial in the natural materials that makes me prefer them. One more thing -- I grew up in the 50s and 60s baitfishing with dimestore cane rods and cheap fiberglass and steel rods. In the early '70s, with a new family and a job that barely paid above minimum wage, I lusted after the new graphite spinning rods, but they were way beyond my means . My first two fly rods were bamboo and fiberglass. Thirty-plus years after graduating from high school, I reached the point where I could get nicer fishing gear, and I tried a few graphite fly rods but quickly settled on bamboo for the reasons mentioned above. I have kept three or four nice graphite rods, mostly for the use of friends and relatives who are afraid of bamboo, but I do fish them now and then and enjoy having them. But I just never had that much experience with graphite, and bamboo is my true love.
Last Edited By: teter 01/08/2009 23:44.
Edited 1 time.
|
||||
|
|
||||
bdcanefly |
#70 | |||
|
I do not own a plastic fly rod and won't buy one.
I have hundreds of bamboo rods. Each one has its own feel. Many by the same company and still a different feel. Like they each have a soul, each one wanting you to get to know it. Some rods never get fished again by me as the feel was not right, but, I still felt them begging me to cast them. I do not think that feel can ever come from a product made of man made material. Or, it could be I am a nut case
BDC
|
||||
|
|
||||
nativebrownie |
#71 | |||
|
Not at all ... makes perfect sense to me.
Last Edited By: nativebrownie 01/14/2009 10:26.
Edited 5 times.
|
||||
|
|
||||
Eric Peper |
#72 | |||
|
Because it makes me happy, and I like being happy.
EP |
||||
|
|
||||